
I’m making biscuits for Charlie Borst this weekend as part of a dinner to accompany a viewing of “To Kill a Mockingbird.” I heard Charlie was doing the cooking and offered to help. He had it under control, he said, but was pondering biscuits.
I’m serious about making biscuits. My mother was serious about making biscuits. My grandmother, who cured her own salt ham, was serious about making biscuits.
Charlie figured he needed about five dozen biscuits for this Southern soiree, so I called my mom. Don’t get me wrong; I make a good biscuit, but we just needed to talk about this upcoming biscuit baking. And, in the course of the conversation, Mom invoked my grandmother, whom we called Maw (really), and then she invoked Maw’s biscuit recipe.
That’s how food conversations go in my family. If it is something that’s a tradition, we have to get to the root of the recipe, then discuss how the recipe has evolved.
Maw made them with lard, then graduated to the thought-to-be-healthier Crisco. Mom used Crisco when I was a kid, I knew. She graduated to half Crisco and half butter, but these days, she said in a guilty stage whisper, she uses all butter.
My mother makes the best biscuits I have ever tasted. And, without a doubt, they are the very best biscuits in all of Fauquier County, and perhaps in all of Virginia. So, here is her recipe, as told to me by phone just last night.

Great grandmaw Hattie Trenis' biscuit cutter with donut attachment
Bobbie Trenis’ biscuits
makes about 10
preheat oven to 425 degrees F
4 T. cold butter, unsalted
——–
2 cups flour
2 1/2 tsp. baking powder
1 tsp. sugar (optional, use 1 T. if you’re using for shortcake)
1/2 tsp. salt
——–
approximately 3/4 cups milk
Mix together the dry ingredients in a medium sized bowl. Mix thoroughly. Cut the butter into about 8 pieces (to make it easier to work in) and put in separate pieces on top of the flour mix. Cut the butter into the flour: you can use a pastry fork or two knives. I’ve done both and they both work well.

Cut in until the butter is the size of small peas.
When the flour mix is full of little butter peas, measure 3/4 cups cold milk.
Make a little well in the flour and pour in about 1/2 cup of milk. Mix lightly with a fork for just a few stirs. You want a moist and tender dough here, so quickly assess if you need more liquid. If it’s a dry, floury dough, add more milk, up to the full amount. Mix the dough fairly well, until there isn’t much dry flour mix in the bottom of the bowl.

Sprinkle a little flour on the counter. Turn out dough onto the surface.

Pull the dough together to make a ball, but don’t work the dough much to do this. Knead the ball by folding it over on itself and flattening it with the palm of your hand. Do this for 11 strokes — no kidding — only 11!

Pat the dough out with your hands or roll with a baking pin to a circle of about 10 inches in diameter. It’ll be about 1/2 inch thick.
Cut with a round cookie cutter, a tuna can with top and bottom cut off, or cut into squares with a knife.

Put on a lightly greased baking sheet OR on parchment on a baking sheet. I use parchment. Mom uses a little vegetable spray. Maw used an ungreased pan.
Put in a hot oven, 425, for about 15 minutes. I bake them on a double (insulated) baking sheet. The biscuits will be nice and brown when they are ready. You know what to do after this.

A couple of notes:
–Mom uses freshly ground soft whole wheat flour these days, unless company is coming.
–These are best eaten the day they are baked. If you eat on subsequent days, split and toast. Serve with butter and jam.
–These make nom shortcake, the kind you tuck under strawberries and cream. Add 1 T. sugar to the dough for this treatment. If you want for-company shortcake, dip the raw biscuits in melted butter, roll in sugar, and bake.

I know in Monroeville, Ala., they eat biscuits. But, if my memory serves from reading “To Kill a Mockingbird” while visiting Nell “Harper” Lee‘s hometown, Scout liked Lane cake, too. (“Miss Maudie baked a Lane cake so loaded with shinny it made me tight.”) That got me curious and hoping for the opportunity to try to make a Lane cake soon. I also plan to plant some camellias in my garden Saturday morning, before the “Mockingbird”showing, and I’ll be thinking of sending graceful blossoms as a gift, in a candy box.
[I added photos Monday, Oct. 26, 2009. Charlie's dinner was wonderful, but it was really Charlie and Elizabeth's. They made fried chicken (Charlie's -- buttermilk and quite perfect), potato salad with sweet and whites (not traditional but so delicious with capers), green beans, salt ham, cole slaw, Elizabeth's corn pudding (tres authentic and delish -- she said whipping cream is her secret), lemon bars, and pecan bars. And, chicory coffee and a real coconut cake brought in to celebrate a birthday. The movie was a delight. No one left hungry. I felt like I had been to a Catlett United Methodist Church supper, circa 1970.]